The short answer
You pick. In Texas, people insured under a homeowners policy are entitled to have their home repaired by the person of their choice. Your insurance company may suggest roofers it works with, and some of them are good, but you don't have to use them.
What Texas says
After Hurricane Harvey, the Texas Department of Insurance reminded insurers, adjusters, and contractors of a Texas rule: homeowners and dwelling policyholders are entitled to have their home repaired by the person they choose. The same bulletin reminded insurers they can't misrepresent what a policy says.
If your insurance company suggests a roofer
Some insurance companies keep a list of contractors and may recommend one. That can work out fine. Before you say yes, ask the same questions you'd ask any roofer:
- Are you local, and how do I reach you next year if something goes wrong?
- Do you carry insurance on your crews and the job?
- Who will actually be on my roof?
- What's the warranty, and who stands behind it?
- On this job, do you work for me or for the insurance company?
How the money works when you pick your own roofer
- Your coverage doesn't change. Your insurance company pays based on its estimate of the damage, minus your deductible, no matter who does the work.
- Missed damage gets documented. If your roofer finds damage the estimate missed, they can document it with photos and an itemized list for your insurance company to review. In Texas, a roofer doing the work can't negotiate your claim or speak for you on coverage. That's for you, a licensed public adjuster, or an attorney.
- Checks go to you. If you have a mortgage, the check is often made out to you and your mortgage company together. Don't sign an insurance check over to a contractor. Pay from an invoice.
- You still pay your deductible. Texas law requires it, and a roofer can't waive, rebate, or absorb it.
Picking well
A good roofer gives you a written contract with a written price, includes the deductible notice Texas requires on insurance jobs of $1,000 or more, and never offers to "take care of" your deductible or "handle" your claim. Ask for proof of insurance and reviews from people near you. And notice who shows up to inspect: will that same person be there on the day of the job?
How KOG works on an insurance roof
We inspect for free and give you a written report with photos of every slope. We'll meet your adjuster on the roof if you want us there, and we do the work your insurance company approves at the price in your contract. We never pay or waive your deductible.
Want us to look at your roof?
The inspection is free, and you get a written report with photos. If there's nothing wrong, we'll tell you that too.
Where this comes from
- Texas Department of Insurance: Commissioner's Bulletin B-0017-17
- Texas Department of Insurance: Roofing and insurance, know the law
- WFAA: Roofing companies busy after North Texas hail (Better Business Bureau tips)
This is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Your policy and your insurance company decide what a claim pays.
More roof guides
- Will insurance pay for a new roof after hail?
The four things that decide a hail roof claim, and what to do if it's denied.
- Should I sign anything before the adjuster comes?
What to read for before you sign, and what Texas law says about roofers and claims.