Roof guides

Why do roof quotes vary so much? Is the cheapest one a mistake?

Updated October 2026 · For Texas homeowners

The short answer

Two quotes that are far apart usually aren't for the same roof. One includes new flashing, new pipe boots, decking, and ventilation work. The other reuses what's there or leaves it out. The cheapest quote isn't always a mistake, but it's often cheaper because it does less. Lay the quotes side by side, line by line, before you decide.

What's usually different between two quotes

  • Tear-off. Does the old roof come off to the deck, or do new shingles go over the old ones?
  • Decking. Is rotten decking priced per sheet in writing, or left out? A low price with no decking price can grow on tear-off day.
  • Underlayment. What kind, and does it cover the whole deck?
  • Flashing and drip edge. New, or reused? Old flashing is where a lot of leaks start.
  • Pipe boots and vents. New, or left in place? They're cheap parts, and often the first to fail.
  • Ventilation. Does the quote check and fix the airflow? A Texas attic that can't breathe cooks shingles from underneath. Here's why that matters.
  • The shingle. Brand, product line, and whether it's impact-rated. An architectural shingle and a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle are very different prices.
  • Permit. Included, and who pulls it?
  • Insurance and crews. Is the roofer insured, and who's actually on your roof?
  • Cleanup and warranty. Haul-off, a magnet sweep for nails, and how many years on labor, in writing.

When the cheapest quote is fine

If it covers the same work with the same materials, comes with a written warranty, and the roofer is insured, local, and can explain the price, a lower quote can be a good deal. Some roofers simply have lower costs, or want the work.

When the cheapest quote costs more

  • Items left out show up later as change orders.
  • Reused flashing and old pipe boots leak years before the shingles wear out.
  • Skipping a permit your city requires can cause trouble with the city, or when you sell.
  • If someone gets hurt on your property, you don't want to find out the roofer had no insurance.

How to compare quotes

  1. Get written quotes for the same job

    One building-safety group suggests at least three. Ask each roofer to quote the same roof, the same way.

  2. Check each quote against the list above

    Mark what each one includes, what it leaves out, and what it reuses.

  3. Ask about anything missing, in writing

    "Does your price include new pipe boots?" A good roofer answers plainly.

  4. Compare the warranties

    Years on labor, the manufacturer's warranty, and what voids them.

  5. Then compare the price

    Now you're comparing the same roof.

If insurance is paying

On an insurance claim, the scope your insurance company approves usually sets the price, and you pay your deductible. Texas law requires it. A roofer who offers a "better deal" by covering your deductible is breaking the law, and telling you how they'll treat you later.

How KOG prices a roof

With the KOG Straight Deal, you get a written price that covers everything: materials, tear-off, labor, cleanup, haul-off, and the warranty. If we find rotten decking, the first 2 sheets are free, and you get photos of every sheet. Nothing extra gets done until you approve it. Want a ballpark first? Try the roof cost calculator.

Want us to look at your roof?

The inspection is free, and you get a written report with photos. If there's nothing wrong, we'll tell you that too.

Where this comes from

This is general information to help you compare quotes. Prices and what's included vary by roofer and by roof.

More roof guides